THE HISTORY OF WOOD RESTORATION
Wood has been used as an article of construction since before
the dawn of civilization.
One of the earliest methods of increasing the durability or
longevity of wood was fire, hardening the tip of a wooden
spear or arrow. This caused the resins in the wood to harden
more than what was produced by the living tree, giving a stronger,
more durable point that more efficiently pierced simple leather
armor, and gave an efficient kill to game animals. This process
also sterilized the wood, which was important since the varieties
of fungi which eat wood are many and common on this planet.
Some varieties of wood also contain natural antibiotics and
these when present help to give the wood longer life by giving
resistance to the micro-organisms that regard wood as food.
Wood used for weapons or other utilitarian articles tended
to wear out before it rotted, while wood used for construction
tended to rot before it wore out. In relative terms, wood
wore out quickly but rotted slowly.
Wood used for architectural purposes only, exhibited long
life under extremely cold conditions or when in an oxygen-free
environment, as the micro-organisms which feed on wood requires
oxygen. The air is about twenty percent oxygen.
Old wooden ships hundreds of years old and buried in mud have
been found and wooden ships and buildings hundreds of years
old and in very good condition have been found in Arctic climates
such as Alaska and northern Canada. It is possible that the
fabled ark of Noah, several thousand years old, has been found
entombed in ice on Mount Ararat in Turkey.
When wood was used at temperatures where fungi and bacteria
are active, the only known technology of "restoration"
was to cut out the deteriorated area and glue in a fitted
replacement portion. In ship repair, in the last hundred years,
the insert was known as a "dutchman". For general
repair and preservation hot tar might be used. While creating
a somewhat waterproof seal with little physical strength,
hot tar tended to sterilize the wood and this plus the tendency
to seal the wood from the air at the location where the hot
tar might be applied, contributed to the longevity of this
technology. The Indians of the North American continent used
tar as a sealant for birch bark canoes.
Tar or Pine pitch or a mixture was commonly used as a sealing
compound between the deck planks of wooden ships hundreds
of years ago. The material was heated and poured into the
seams where it solidified. The decks were thus sealed against
water and rain leaking through to the cabins below. The sailors
were usually barefoot and on hot days the tar would melt and
transfer to the soles of the feet. British sailors thus acquired
the nickname "tarheels".
The surface protection of wood was accomplished by treatment
with the oils of various beans, berries or seeds which had
been found to dry and harden on exposure to the air. This
material, today, we call varnish.
Joints between separate pieces of wood on older boats were
usually filled with a paste of fibrous material, lead oxide,
and various vegetable oils or varnishes. The lead oxide served
as a primitive fungicide to deter the rot which would begin
when the inevitable fungus spores, carried by air or water,
got into the space between two pieces of wood and proceeded
to hatch, grow, and eat the wood.
An early method of increasing the rot resistance of wooden
ships was to paint the masts, spars and other parts black.
This absorbed more heat form the sun, dried out the wood after
it had been rained upon, and thus fungal decay was reduced
by keeping the wood more dry more of the time.
The marine environment is hundreds of times more severe than
the architectural environment, in terms of both dampness and
mechanical stress. Technology was thus forced to develop for
marine maintenance and restoration, where little technology
was forced to develop for architectural maintenance and restoration.
The Dawn of Contemporary Wood Restoration Technology
In the 1950's Shell Chemical Company invented a commercial
process for manufacturing a type of resin and a variety of
curing agents for it. The family of adhesives and coatings
which were developed from these products turned out to be
surprisingly versatile and compatible with a wide range of
wood and metal and concrete materials. The U.S. Department
of Defense rapidly developed improved versions of these paints
and adhesives in their own research laboratories, to meet
a wide range of military applications. They then solicited
bids from the existing paint industry to manufacture these
formulations. The industrial community was thus given a "jump-start"
in commercializing products based on these resins.
Many large and small companies began to make "commercialized"
or lower-cost versions of military formulations and to offer
them to industry and the general public for just about any
possible application, with no serious applications technology.
By the late 1960's ~ 1970's many small businesses had developed
architectural maintenance products which were moderately successful,
although a common failure mechanism was that some one to a
few years later a filler in the wood might be seen to come
loose and rise up under a coat of paint, or rot to start up
again behind a spot that had been "treated" with
some "restoration" product. These architectural
maintenance products could not cross over successfully into
the marine market place, as the quality of restoration possible
in the architectural market was such that with luck a repair
might last five or ten years; in a marine environment that
same quality of repair might last three months to two years.
The technology was not viable in the more severe marine environment
and only barely viable in the architectural environment.
Thus, there were no epoxy restoration products successful
and expanding in either the marine or architectural market
places.
In 1972 Steve Smith became aware of the need for something
to handle deteriorated wood on boats from a friend in the
marine business. He whipped up something and told his friend
to "try this". The short term results were so successful
that a demand appeared almost overnight, and the first formulation
of the Lignu® Impregnating Resin (as it would come to
be known thirty years later), embodying the fundamental principles
of the technology (though far from optimum) was introduced
to the marine marketplace. By 1976 the product had spread
to the architectural restoration marketplace, a filler and
a glue had been added to the product line, and sales volume
had dramatically increased, with the business growing from
one person to six employees.
Meanwhile, the technology was evolving and becoming optimized
and more refined as the actual needs of the end users become
better understood. Various painting contractors and remodeling
contractors had begun to use the product for routine maintenance
and restoration. The State of California State Architect's
office and the State of California Department of Parks and
Recreation found out about the products, evaluated them and
began to use them for the restoration of various historic
structures.
A boat builder who happened to be working for the U.S. Government,
stationed on Kwajalein Atoll in the South Pacific (part of
the Pacific Missile Test Range), found that the Lignu Impregnating
Resin was useful in the maintenance of the wood buildings
on Kwajalein which housed the radar and electronics gear.
Thereafter anywhere from thirty to two hundred gallons every
few months were sold to the U.S. Government and shipped to
Kwajalein for continuing restoration of the wood buildings.
This is significant because Kwajalein is hot, humid, and gets
about a hundred inches a year of rainfall. The product was
successful in maintaining old and new wood buildings that,
before this time, were simply torn down and replaced every
few years. This continued thought the end of the Cold War
and the closure of the Pacific Missile Test Range in the early
'90's. The radar station is now used as a mid-Pacific air
traffic flight control center, and the use of this product
continues.
Thus, once a viable technology for the restoration of deteriorated
wood in a marine environment was developed, it spread and
expanded rapidly in the architectural maintenance market place
since it was an inherently viable technology.
The Modern Technology that restores deteriorated wood.
The technology underwent significant refinements in the
laboratory in the late 80's and early 90's but none of this
was released to the public since it was felt that a better
customer training program would be needed to take best advantage
of the latest refinements. The present customers had learned
about the products through word-of-mouth or some limited advertising,
and the only training possible for mail-order customers was
the enclosed literature package. After observing the effectiveness
of such training, Steve Smith decided that the newer, high-performance
versions would only be used by those formally trained in a
classroom environment due to the much better and more consistent
results available from such training.
These "consumer-grade" products had, over the years,
gained great acceptance among end users, including some pest
control operators ("Exterminators") who used the
product to restore deteriorated wood despite written rules
from their regulatory agency stating deteriorated wood must
be removed. The technology did not have a theoretically derived
origin but rather an experimental one. Thus, no authorities
in the Forest Sciences Departments of Universities had evaluated
the product and measured the properties of restored wood and
certified that some percentage of restoration could be reproducibly
achieved and measured under standard test conditions. This
is in fact impossible, since there is no such thing as a standard
piece of rotten wood. Thus, no restoration standard was possible.
City building inspectors were now commonly coming into contact
with the products and their use in a variety of circumstances
and more questions arose, as restoration of deteriorated wood
is not covered by any building code. Yet, people were using
it and it seemed to work, the test being to jab the wood with
an ice pick to assess the state of deterioration by the degree
of penetration. After treatment with the Lignu Impregnating
Resin, the treated wood resisted penetration by an ice pick
in a similar manner that new wood did. Thus, restoration was
accomplished in fact if not in law.
In 1997 a surrogate standard for deteriorated wood was invented
by the discovery that the common cedar shingle had a very
similar absorption of Lignu Impregnating Resin as lightly
rotted wood. A series of tests were then done, using the professional
Version , comparing treated wood and untreated wood,
and actually measuring the effects of restoration of wood
with this technology. The results are published at www.woodrestoration.com.
The building code and pest-control-operator ("Exterminator")
regulations do now address restoration. References are cited
at the end of the above publication.
The Future of the Restoration of Deteriorated Wood.
The development of the professional versions of these products
has now been accomplished, based on the knowledge gained and
refinements and field tests and evaluation of the last 24
years. The trademark Lignu was created and registered to denote
the modern, high-performance family of wood restoration products.
A training program for the use of these products has been
developed and technicians have been trained and are capable
of applying the products and the underlying technology.
In the Spring of 2001 the Lignu Specification was published
on the U. S. site of www.lignu.com, and the State of California
department of the State Architect issued guidelines for restoration
of deteriorated wood on all State property overseen by them,
including schools. This applies to structural as well as non-structural
wood elements.
Wood is commonly used in construction, has been for hundreds
of years and will certainly continue to be for hundreds of
years due to the low cost and high production rate of wood
by the natural vegetable life forms of this planet.
Since the technology relies on restoration of deteriorated
wood using, in great part, materials actually derived from
wood, these products and this technology will persist as long
as wood itself is used in architectural construction.
Copyright © 2002 Steve Smith All rights reserved
|